I feel like I'm the only person in the kidlitosphere that is apathetic about the Youth Media Awards. Even my friend Sara who doesn't blog outside of once a year dedicated our daily email thread to them. Am I the Grinch that stole the Awards Ceremony? Granted, I did not fashion my aged dog and myself in spiffy outfits and take the correspondences into a red sack, all the while laughingly maniacally. This much is true, but I still am all bah-humbug! about this stuff.
When I was a kid Newberry books were something you had to read for school over and over again, and therefore sucked. Now that I'm a librarian I'm supposed to get giddy about it? I can still see that strained look when kids come into the library with their Newberry assignments, so I know this hasn't changed much in the past decade. I know there are kids out there that get excited about the award books, but from my personal experience they are younger and care about the Caldecott. I honestly tried to be proactive about them the summer before library school started and ... fail. The books I read were enjoyable but that nagging feeling that I was reading a Newberry clouded my brain. Prejudices die hard.
So, Kidlitters, I implore you to show me why I should care about this. Yeah, it's a bit of a demand and yeah, I'm aware 2 people read this but still... IMPLORE!
Note: What do I know? I'm not even a for-real librarian yet, what with that pesky graduation 4 months away. Also: I love Animorphs which should serve as several grains of salt in and of itself.
Tuesday, January 27, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
So - its a 'snow day' which means time to be aimless with my laptop. I came to look at the outsider review and ended up browsing your blog! Nice job btw. And Hurrah! - I am not alone in avoidance of and lack of respect for the award winners! maybe the new award will be better? can't help it- optimism is a fault of mine! see ya nxt class
Okay good, I'm glad I'm not alone. All the hubbub made me feel like there was something wrong with me--like I'm a defective librarian or something!
I guess in some ways I see the awards process as sort of a similar thing to the posting-of-the-cast-list for a play that I know I'm doing crew for anyway. It doesn't directly affect me, but I'm happy to cheer on the 'winners,' discuss on who got what and who didn't, enjoy the gossip, speculate on how each cast member will be received in the role, etc.
(hello, Terri!)
Well, I'll say that the biggest reason I was all excited was Neil Gaiman, because, outside of kidlit, he is one of my favorite authors. And it is pretty exciting to have actually heard of the book beforehand. Yay creepy children's books!
I was at Midwinter and slept through the awards because I didn't want to wake up that early. I have respect for the process and the work involved. I think what people get excited about is that this is our nationally recognized award. Papers actually publish this. Many times the library does stuff and no one cares or no one notices. This is one time that the press seems to always post the results. This is our Oscar, baby. That said, I think choosing which book is the most distinguished of the year is quite subjective and will be different to each person. There is no clear winner.
Yeah I figured as much, Sara. :)
You <3 the Gaiman fo sho.
Zee, I think your explanation did what I was hoping this post would accomplish. I now have respect for the Newberry in a way that I didn't previously because I am all about libraries attention whoring it up (in a + way, that is).
Post a Comment